Vasopressor drugs for the prevention and treatment of hypotension during neuraxial anaesthesia for Caesarean delivery: a Bayesian network meta-analysis of fetal and maternal outcomes

Published:December 04, 2019DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bja.2019.09.045

      Abstract

      Background

      The optimal choice of vasopressor drugs for managing hypotension during neuraxial anaesthesia for Caesarean delivery is unclear. Although phenylephrine was recently recommended as a consensus choice, direct comparison of phenylephrine with vasopressors used in other healthcare settings is largely lacking. Therefore, we assessed this indirectly by collating data from relevant studies in this comprehensive network meta-analysis. Here, we provide the possible rank orders for these vasopressor agents in relation to clinically important fetal and maternal outcomes.

      Methods

      RCTs were independently searched in MEDLINE, Web of Science, Embase, The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and clinicaltrials.gov (updated January 31, 2019). The primary outcome assessed was umbilical arterial base excess. Secondary fetal outcomes were umbilical arterial pH and P co 2. Maternal outcomes were incidences of nausea, vomiting, and bradycardia.

      Results

      We included 52 RCTs with a total of 4126 patients. Our Bayesian network meta-analysis showed the likelihood that norepinephrine, metaraminol, and mephentermine had the lowest probability of adversely affecting the fetal acid-base status as assessed by their effect on umbilical arterial base excess (probability rank order: norepinephrine > mephentermine > metaraminol > phenylephrine > ephedrine). This rank order largely held true for umbilical arterial pH and P co 2. With the exception of maternal bradycardia, ephedrine had the highest probability of being the worst agent for all assessed outcomes. Because of the inherent imprecision when collating direct/indirect comparisons, the rank orders suggested are possibilities rather than absolute ranks.

      Conclusion

      Our analysis suggests the possibility that norepinephrine and metaraminol are less likely than phenylephrine to be associated with adverse fetal acid-base status during Caesarean delivery. Our results, therefore, lay the scientific foundation for focused trials to enable direct comparisons between these agents and phenylephrine.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      References

        • Reynolds F.
        • Seed P.T.
        Anaesthesia for Caesarean section and neonatal acid-base status: a meta-analysis.
        Anaesthesia. 2005; 60: 636-653
        • Corke B.C.
        • Datta S.
        • Ostheimer G.W.
        • Weiss J.B.
        • Alper M.H.
        Spinal anaesthesia for Caesarean section. The influence of hypotension on neonatal outcome.
        Anaesthesia. 1982; 37: 658-662
        • Okudaira S.
        • Suzuki S.
        Influence of spinal hypotension on fetal oxidative status during elective cesarean section in uncomplicated pregnancies.
        Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2005; 271: 292-295
        • Campbell J.P.
        • Stocks G.M.
        Management of hypotension with vasopressors at caesarean section under spinal anaesthesia – have we found the Holy Grail of obstetric anaesthesia?.
        Anaesthesia. 2018; 73: 3-6
        • Butwick A.J.
        • Columb M.O.
        • Carvalho B.
        Preventing spinal hypotension during Caesarean delivery: what is the latest?.
        Br J Anaesth. 2015; 114: 183-186
        • Lin F.-Q.
        • Qiu M.-T.
        • Ding X.-X.
        • Fu S.-K.
        • Li Q.
        Ephedrine versus phenylephrine for the management of hypotension during spinal anesthesia for cesarean section: an updated meta-analysis.
        CNS Neurosci Ther. 2012; 18: 591-597
        • Xu C.
        • Liu S.
        • Huang Y.
        • Guo X.
        • Xiao H.
        • Qi D.
        Phenylephrine vs ephedrine in cesarean delivery under spinal anesthesia: a systematic literature review and meta-analysis.
        Int J Surg. 2018; 60: 48-59
        • Heesen M.
        • Klöhr S.
        • Rossaint R.
        • Straube S.
        Prophylactic phenylephrine for caesarean section under spinal anaesthesia: systematic review and meta-analysis.
        Anaesthesia. 2014; 69: 143-165
        • Heesen M.
        • Rijs K.
        • Hilber N.
        • et al.
        Ephedrine versus phenylephrine as a vasopressor for spinal anaesthesia-induced hypotension in parturients undergoing high-risk caesarean section: meta-analysis, meta-regression and trial sequential analysis.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 2019; 37: 16-28
        • Liberati A.
        • Altman D.G.
        • Tetzlaff J.
        • et al.
        The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration.
        PLoS Med. 2009; 6e1000100
        • Hozo S.P.
        • Djulbegovic B.
        • Hozo I.
        Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and the size of a sample.
        BMC Med Res Methodol. 2005; 5: 13
        • Thiessen Philbrook H.
        • Barrowman N.
        • Garg A.X.
        Imputing variance estimates do not alter the conclusions of a meta-analysis with continuous outcomes: a case study of changes in renal function after living kidney donation.
        J Clin Epidemiol. 2007; 60: 228-240
        • Chowdhry A.K.
        • Dworkin R.H.
        • McDermott M.P.
        Meta-analysis with missing study-level sample variance data.
        Stat Med. 2016; 35: 3021-3032
        • Lundh A.
        • Gøtzsche P.C.
        Recommendations by Cochrane Review Groups for assessment of the risk of bias in studies.
        BMC Med Res Methodol. 2008; 8: 1-9
        • Doi S.A.R.
        • Barendregt J.J.
        A generalized pairwise modelling framework for network meta-analysis.
        Int J Evid Based Healthc. 2018; 16: 187-194
        • Dias S.
        • Welton N.J.
        • Sutton A.J.
        • Caldwell D.M.
        • Lu G.
        • Ades A.E.
        Evidence synthesis for decision making 4: inconsistency in networks of evidence based on randomized controlled trials.
        Med Decis Making. 2013; 33: 641-656
        • Batson S.
        • Sutton A.
        • Abrams K.
        Exploratory network meta regression analysis of stroke prevention in atrial fibrillation fails to identify any interactions with treatment effect.
        PLoS One. 2016; 11e0161864
        • Dias S.
        • Sutton A.J.
        • Welton N.J.
        • Ades A.E.
        Evidence synthesis for decision making 3: heterogeneity—subgroups, meta-regression, bias, and bas-adjustment.
        Med Decis Making. 2013; 33: 618-640
        • Magalhães E.
        • Govêia C.S.
        • de Araújo Ladeira L.C.
        • Nascimento B.G.
        • Kluthcouski S.M.C.
        Ephedrine versus phenylephrine: prevention of hypotension during spinal block for cesarean section and effects on the fetus.
        Rev Bras Anestesiol. 2009; 59: 11-20
        • Wang M.
        • Han C.-B.
        • Qian Y.-N.
        Comparison of effects in puerpera and fetus with ephedrine and phenylephrine during a cesarean delivery.
        Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2011; 91 (in Chinese): 2195-2198
        • Alday E.M.
        • Palacio F.A.
        • De R.D.
        • Gilsanz F.R.
        Ephedrine vs. phenylephrine by intravenous bolus and continuous infusion to prevent hypotension secondary to spinal anesthesia during cesarean section: a randomized comparative trial.
        Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim. 2011; 58 ([in Spanish]): 412-416
        • Amiri H.A.
        • Banihashem F.
        • Naziri F.
        • Rabiee M.
        • Ghasemi A.
        • Shirkhani Z.
        The effects of phenylephrine and ephedrine on maternal hemodynamic changes and neonatal acid-base Status during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        J Mazand Univ Med Sci. 2013; 23: 117-124
        • de Aragão F.F.
        • de Aragão P.W.
        • de Souza Martins C.A.
        • Salgado Filho N.
        • Barroqueiro Ede S.
        Comparison of metaraminol, phenylephrine and ephedrine in prophylaxis and treatment of hypotension in cesarean section under spinal anesthesia.
        Rev Brasil Anestesiolog. 2014; 64: 299-306
        • Moran D.H.
        • Perillo M.
        • LaPorta R.F.
        • Bader A.M.
        • Datta S.
        Phenylephrine in the prevention of hypotension following spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        J Clin Anesth. 1991; 3: 301-305
        • Hall P.A.
        • Bennett A.
        • Wilkes M.P.
        • Lewis M.
        Spinal anaesthesia for caesarean section: comparison of infusions of phenylephrine and ephedrine.
        Br J Anaesth. 1994; 73: 471-474
        • Pierce E.T.
        • Carr D.B.
        • Datta S.
        Effects of ephedrine and phenylephrine on maternal and fetal atrial natriuretic peptide levels during elective cesarean section.
        Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 1994; 38: 48-51
        • LaPorta R.F.
        • Arthur G.R.
        • Datta S.
        Phenylephrine in treating maternal hypotension due to spinal anaesthesia for caesarean delivery: effects on neonatal catecholamine concentrations, acid base status and Apgar scores.
        Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 1995; 39: 901-905
        • Thomas D.G.
        • Robson S.C.
        • Redfern N.
        • Hughes D.
        • Boys R.J.
        Randomized trial of bolus phenylephrine or ephedrine for maintenance of arterial pressure during spinal anaesthesia for Caesarean section.
        Br J Anaesth. 1996; 76: 61-65
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Lau T.K.
        • Khaw K.S.
        • Lee B.B.
        Comparison of metaraminol and ephedrine infusions for maintaining arterial pressure during spinal anesthesia for elective cesarean section.
        Anesthesiology. 2001; 95: 307-313
        • Cooper D.W.
        • Carpenter M.
        • Mowbray P.
        • Desira W.R.
        • Ryall D.M.
        • Kokri M.S.
        Fetal and maternal effects of phenylephrine and ephedrine during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        Anesthesiology. 2002; 97: 1582-1590
        • Kansal A.
        • Mohta M.
        • Sethi A.K.
        • Tyagi A.
        • Kumar P.
        Randomised trial of intravenous infusion of ephedrine or mephentermine for management of hypotension during spinal anaesthesia for Caesarean section.
        Anaesthesia. 2005; 60: 28-34
        • Jung S.W.
        • Kim E.J.
        • Min B.W.
        • Ban J.S.
        • Lee S.G.
        • Lee J.H.
        Comparison of maternal and fetal effects of ephedrine and phenylephrine infusion during spinal anesthesia for cesarean section.
        Korean J Anesthesiol. 2006; 51: 335-342
        • Saravanan S.
        • Kocarev M.
        • Wilson R.C.
        • Watkins E.
        • Columb M.O.
        • Lyons G.
        Equivalent dose of ephedrine and phenylephrine in the prevention of post-spinal hypotension in Caesarean section.
        Br J Anaesth. 2006; 96: 95-99
        • Cooper D.W.
        • Gibb S.C.
        • Meek T.
        • et al.
        Effect of intravenous vasopressor on spread of spinal anaesthesia and fetal acid-base equilibrium.
        Br J Anaesth. 2007; 98: 649-656
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Lee A.
        • Khaw K.S.
        • Ng F.F.
        • Karmakar M.K.
        • Gin T.
        A randomized double-blinded comparison of phenylephrine and ephedrine infusion combinations to maintain blood pressure during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery: the effects on fetal acid-base status and hemodynamic control.
        Anesth Analg. 2008; 107: 1295-1302
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Khaw K.S.
        • Lau T.K.
        • Ng F.F.
        • Chui K.
        • Ng K.L.
        Randomised double-blinded comparison of phenylephrine vs ephedrine for maintaining blood pressure during spinal anaesthesia for non-elective Caesarean section.
        Anaesthesia. 2008; 63: 1319-1326
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Khaw K.S.
        • Tan P.E.
        • Ng F.F.
        • Karmakar M.K.
        Placental transfer and fetal metabolic effects of phenylephrine and ephedrine during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        Anesthesiology. 2009; 111: 506-512
        • Gunda C.P.
        • Malinowski J.
        • Tegginmath A.
        • Suryanarayana V.G.
        • Chandra S.B.C.
        Vasopressor choice for hypotension in elective Cesarean section: ephedrine or phenylephrine?.
        Arch Med Sci. 2010; 6: 257-263
        • Mahajan L.
        • Anand L.K.
        • Gombar K.K.
        A randomized double-blinded comparison of ephedrine, phenylephrine and mephentermine infusions to maintain blood pressure during spinal anaesthesia for cesarean delivery: the effects on fetal acid-base status and haemodynamic control.
        J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol. 2009; 25: 427-432
        • Hennebry M.C.
        • Stocks G.M.
        • Belavadi P.
        • et al.
        Effect of i.v. phenylephrine or ephedrine on the ED50 of intrathecal bupivacaine with fentanyl for caesarean section.
        Br J Anaesth. 2009; 102: 806-811
        • Dyer R.A.
        • Reed A.R.
        • van Dyk D.
        • et al.
        Hemodynamic effects of ephedrine, phenylephrine, and the coadministration of phenylephrine with oxytocin during spinal anesthesia for elective cesarean delivery.
        Anesthesiology. 2009; 111: 753-765
        • Prakash S.
        • Pramanik V.
        • Chellani H.
        • Salhan S.
        • Gogia A.R.
        Maternal and neonatal effects of bolus administration of ephedrine and phenylephrine during spinal anaesthesia for caesarean delivery: a randomised study.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 2010; 19: 24-30
        • Guillon A.
        • Leyre S.
        • Remérand F.
        • et al.
        Modification of Tp-e and QTc intervals during caesarean section under spinal anaesthesia.
        Anaesthesia. 2010; 65: 337-342
        • Mohta M.
        • Janani S.S.
        • Sethi A.K.
        • Agarwal D.
        • Tyagi A.
        Comparison of phenylephrine hydrochloride and mephentermine sulphate for prevention of post spinal hypotension.
        Anaesthesia. 2010; 65: 1200-1205
        • Das S.
        • Mukhopadhyay S.
        • Mandal M.
        • Mandal S.
        • Basu S.R.
        A comparative study of infusions of phenylephrine, ephedrine and phenylephrine plus ephedrine on maternal haemodynamics in elective caesarean section.
        Indian J Anaesth. 2011; 55: 578-583
        • Yadav U.
        • Bharat K.
        A clinical comparative study of prophylactic infusions of phenylephrine and ephedrine on maternal hemodynamics and fetal acidosis in elective caesarean section.
        IJPSR. 2012; 3: 5056-5061
        • Nazir I.
        • Bhat M.A.
        • Qazi S.
        • Buchh V.N.
        • Gurcoo S.A.
        Comparison between phenylephrine and ephedrine in preventing hypotension during spinal anesthesia for cesarean section.
        J Obstet Anaesth Crit Care. 2012; 2: 92-97
        • Bhardwaj N.
        • Jain K.
        • Arora S.
        • Bharti N.
        A comparison of three vasopressors for tight control of maternal blood pressure during cesarean section under spinal anesthesia: effect on maternal and fetal outcome.
        J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol. 2013; 29: 26-31
        • Odagme M.T.
        • Fyneface-Ogan
        • Mato C.N.
        Prophylactic infusions of phenylephrine and ephedrine during combined spinal epidural anaesthesia for Caesarean section: a comparative study.
        J Anesth Clin Res. 2013; 4: 357
        • Jain K.
        • Makkar J.K.
        • Anbarasan I.
        • Yadanappudi S.
        • Gander S.
        A randomized double-blind comparison of low-dose and high-dose bupivacaine for caesarean section in severely preeclamptic women using invasive blood pressure monitoring.
        J Obstet Anaesth Crit Care. 2013; 3: 84
        • Foss V.T.
        • Christensen R.
        • Rokamp K.Z.
        • Nissen P.
        • Secher N.H.
        • Nielsen H.B.
        Effect of phenylephrine vs. ephedrine on frontal lobe oxygenation during caesarean section with spinal anesthesia: an open label randomized controlled trial.
        Front Physiol. 2014; 5: 81
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Lee S.W.Y.
        • Ng F.F.
        • Tan P.E.
        • Khaw K.S.
        Randomized double-blinded comparison of norepinephrine and phenylephrine for maintenance of blood pressure during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        Anesthesiology. 2015; 122: 736-745
        • Natarajan A.K.
        • Singh N.R.
        • Singh L.P.
        • Devi R.S.
        • Devi N.A.
        • Jack A.
        Comparison of intravenous bolus phenylephrine and intravenous ephedrine during crystalloid coloading in ameliorating hypotension under spinal anesthesia for caesarean section.
        J Med Soc. 2015; 29: 155-159
        • Siddiqui A.S.
        • Salim B.
        • Siddiqui S.Z.
        Comparison of phenylephrine and ephedrine for treating hypotension after spinal anesthesia for cesarean section: a randomized double-blind clinical trial.
        Anaesth Pain Intensive Care. 2015; 19
        • Moslemi F.
        • Rasooli S.
        Comparison of prophylactic infusion of phenylephrine with ephedrine for prevention of hypotension in elective cesarean section under spinal anesthesia: a randomized clinical trial.
        Iran J Med Sci. 2015; 40: 19-26
        • Guo R.
        • Xue Q.
        • Qian Y.
        • Hu Y.
        • Tan J.
        The effects of ephedrine and phenylephrine on placental vascular resistance during cesarean section under epidual anesthesia.
        Cell Biochem Biophys. 2015; 73: 687-693
        • Mohta M.
        • Aggarwal M.
        • Sethi A.K.
        • Harisinghani P.
        • Guleria K.
        Randomized double-blind comparison of ephedrine and phenylephrine for management of post-spinal hypotension in potential fetal compromise.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 2016; 27: 32-40
        • Soxhuku-Isufi A.
        • Shpata V.
        • Sula H.
        Maternal and neonatal effects of vasopressors used for treating hypotension after spinal anesthesia for caesarean section: a randomized controlled study.
        Open Access Maced J Med Sci. 2016; 4: 54-58
        • McDonnell N.J.
        • Paech M.J.
        • Muchatuta N.A.
        • Hillyard S.
        • Nathan E.A.
        A randomised double-blind trial of phenylephrine and metaraminol infusions for prevention of hypotension during spinal and combined spinal-epidural anaesthesia for elective caesarean section.
        Anaesthesia. 2017; 72: 609-617
        • Dong L.
        • Dong Q.
        • Song X.
        • Liu Y.
        • Wang Y.
        Comparison of prophylactic bolus norepinephrine and phenylephrine on hypotension during spinal anesthesia for cesarean section.
        Int J Clin Exp Med. 2017; 10: 12315-12321
        • Vallejo M.C.
        • Attaallah A.F.
        • Elzamzamy O.M.
        • et al.
        An open-label randomized controlled clinical trial for comparison of continuous phenylephrine versus norepinephrine infusion in prevention of spinal hypotension during cesarean delivery.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 2017; 29: 18-25
        • Vakili H.
        • Enayati H.
        • Dashipour A.
        Comparing intravenous phenylephrine and ephedrine for hypotension during spinal anesthesia for elective cesarean section: a randomized double-blind clinical trial.
        Iran Red Crescent Med J. 2017; 19e13978
        • Mon W.
        • Stewart A.
        • Fernando R.
        • et al.
        Cardiac output changes with phenylephrine and ephedrine infusions during spinal anesthesia for cesarean section: a randomized, double-blind trial.
        J Clin Anesth. 2017; 37: 43-48
        • Dyer R.A.
        • Emmanuel A.
        • Adams S.C.
        • et al.
        A randomised comparison of bolus phenylephrine and ephedrine for the management of spinal hypotension in patients with severe preeclampsia and fetal compromise.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 2018; 33: 23-31
        • Higgins N.
        • Fitzgerald P.C.
        • van Dyk D.
        • et al.
        The effect of prophylactic phenylephrine and ephedrine infusions on umbilical artery blood pH in women with preeclampsia undergoing cesarean delivery with spinal anesthesia: a randomized, double-blind trial.
        Anesth Analg. 2018; 126: 1999-2006
        • Singh R.
        • Verma R.
        • Bhatia V.K.
        • Chaudhary A.K.
        • Chandra G.
        A comparative study of phenylephrine and ephedrine combination to ephedrine and phenylephrine alone for maintenance of blood pressure for caesarean delivery and their effects on foetal acid base status.
        J Obstet Anaesth Crit Care. 2018; 8: 29
        • Dyer R.A.
        • Daniels A.
        • Vorster A.
        • et al.
        Maternal cardiac output response to colloid preload and vasopressor therapy during spinal anaesthesia for caesarean section in patients with severe pre-eclampsia: a randomised, controlled trial.
        Anaesthesia. 2018; 73: 23-31
        • Sharkey A.M.
        • Siddiqui N.
        • Downey K.
        • Ye X.Y.
        • Guevara J.
        • Carvalho J.C.A.
        Comparison of intermittent intravenous boluses of phenylephrine and norepinephrine to prevent and treat spinal-induced hypotension in cesarean deliveries: randomized controlled trial.
        Anesth Analg. 2018; 129: 1312-1318
        • Elnabtity A.M.
        • Selim M.F.
        Norepinephrine versus ephedrine to maintain arterial blood pressure during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery: a prospective double-blinded trial.
        Anesth Essays Res. 2018; 12: 92-97
        • Mohta M.
        • Duggal S.
        • Chilkoti G.T.
        Randomised double-blind comparison of bolus phenylephrine or ephedrine for treatment of hypotension in women with pre-eclampsia undergoing caesarean section.
        Anaesthesia. 2018; 73: 839-846
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Khaw K.S.
        • Tan P.E.
        • Ng F.F.
        • Karmakar M.K.
        Placental transfer and fetal metabolic effects of phenylephrine and ephedrine during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        Anesthesiology. 2009; 111: 506-512
        • Kinsella S.M.
        • Carvalho B.
        • Dyer R.A.
        • et al.
        International consensus statement on the management of hypotension with vasopressors during caesarean section under spinal anaesthesia.
        Anaesthesia. 2018; 73: 71-92
        • Thorp J.A.
        • Rushing R.S.
        Umbilical cord blood gas analysis.
        Obstet Gynecol Clin North Am. 1999; 26: 695-709
        • Lee A.
        • Ngan Kee W.D.
        • Gin T.
        A quantitative, systematic review of randomized controlled trials of ephedrine versus phenylephrine for the management of hypotension during spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery.
        Anesth Analg. 2002; 94: 920-926
        • Mohta M.
        Phenylephrine — need for another formulation.
        Br J Anaesth. 2011; 107https://doi.org/10.1093/bja/el_6989